Why Does the Popcorn Bag Tell You to Skip the Popcorn Button?

The microwave has a button just for popcorn. The popcorn would like a word. Pug DJ hears out both sides before movie night.

Somewhere on a microwave keypad, a potato has its own button. So does popcorn. The potato, as far as I know, has kept its feelings private. The popcorn has issued a statement.

Pop Secret’s instructions tell you to skip the popcorn button. Imagine being a button with one food printed on your face and learning that the food has asked to work with somebody else. As a pug with a face made for bad news, I feel for the little guy. Pop Secret’s popping instructions.

What the button does · Why the bag gets a vote · Back to the movie

What the button actually does

GE Appliances describes two kinds of popcorn buttons on its microwaves. One runs for a preset time chosen for an average package. The other senses steam coming from the bag and uses that information to estimate how much cooking time is left. Which one you have, and which bag sizes it supports, depends on the model. GE’s guide to the popcorn button.

I like the steam idea. There’s something sweet about an appliance that pays that much attention to a snack. I also have some sympathy for the timer. Somebody asked it to make popcorn, gave it a clock and sent it out into the world with startling confidence.

The bag gets a vote

Here’s where the two instructions make peace. The appliance maker knows what its button can do. The popcorn maker knows what’s in the bag. Even GE tells people using microwave popcorn bags to follow the popcorn manufacturer’s directions. A perfectly good button can sit this movie out. GE’s advice for bagged popcorn.

For its own popcorn, Pop Secret says to follow the box, stay by the microwave and listen. Its cue to stop is when there’s about a second or two between pops. If you’ve got a different brand in your hand, give its directions a look. There’s no prize for remembering somebody else’s popcorn time. Pop Secret’s FAQ.

A small proposal for movie night

I’d make one change to the box. Put that listening cue in type big enough to read while standing at the counter. Give it some of the real estate currently devoted to a photograph of butter. I believe everybody involved in movie night already understands the appeal of butter.

Then let the person making the popcorn listen in peace. The streaming service can wait. So can the discussion about whether everyone has already seen this movie. Give the human at the microwave one quiet minute to conduct a very small orchestra.

As for the last unpopped kernel rattling around in the bowl? That’s the maraca. Every good band needs one.